Note sent to the United Synagogue of Hoboken community, Sunday June 26, 2022:
Many of us have been especially focused on the Supreme Court decision released on Friday that overturns Roe vs. Wade and eliminates a federally assured right to abortion. Already, trigger laws in several states make most abortions illegal currently or imminently.
The comments below are excerpted from my comments during yesterday's Shabbat morning service at the United Synagogue of Hoboken.
There is a lot to say about the issue of abortion from a Jewish point of view. And there is a lot of disagreement. But I would like to share with you three fundamental points of agreement across the Jewish spectrum.
In Judaism, the fetus does not have the same rights of personhood as the mother, at ANY point during pregnancy. The classic traditional Jewish source expressing this is the Mishnah, Ohalot 7:6, https://www.sefaria.org/Mishnah_Oholot.7.6?vhe=Torat_Emet_357&lang=bi&with=all&lang2=en, and the various sources derived from it. The idea that full rights of personhood kick in at the moment of conception is an idea that can be found in Christian writings, including some Catholic and Evangelical communities, but it is not an idea that you can find in traditional Jewish texts. I have no objection to people holding this perspective based on their deeply held religious beliefs, but it should not be imposed on those who do not share those religious beliefs.
Abortion is permitted and even required according to Jewish law if the potential harm to the mother warrants it. Different rabbis at different times have different opinions about how we understand “potential harm to the mother,” and this is the primary way that different Jewish legal authorities have differed from each other on the question of abortion. But note that evaluating “potential harm to the mother” is exactly the calculus that any pregnant person contemplating abortion is considering.
“Mental health” is part of “health.” Today fortunately there is an evolving consensus across the Jewish spectrum that we are obviously including mental health as part of what the word “health” means -- and that a concern about the mental health of the person who is pregnant can justify abortion.
When I talk and teach about Jewish perspectives on abortion, I tend especially to quote Orthodox sources. Clearly I am not Orthodox, and I don’t necessarily agree with the totality of these Orthodox sources, but there is such obvious unanimity among non-Orthodox Jewish organizations that abortion should remain safe and legal, that any quotations of the statements of non-Orthodox organizations and leaders tend to sound obvious. But the Orthodox organizations also have consensus on these three points above, though their perspectives are seen as less obvious.
Jewish law prioritizes the life of the pregnant mother over the life of the fetus such that where the pregnancy critically endangers the physical health or mental health of the mother, an abortion may be authorized, if not mandated, by Halacha and should be available to all women irrespective of their economic status. Legislation and court rulings -- federally or in any state -- that absolutely ban abortion without regard for the health of the mother would literally limit our ability to live our lives in accordance with our responsibility to preserve life.
At two different points in this statement, there are specific references to how “health” includes “mental health,” in part because some of the bills being considered in some states, if they have exceptions to save the life of the mother, specify that they’re talking about “physical health,” to specifically exclude mental health considerations. However, the mental anguish of the person who is pregnant has, for centuries, been considered as part of the decision-making criteria for abortion in Jewish law, and the OU felt it was necessary to emphasize this.
Additionally, the OU statement makes it clear that there is a real concern that some state abortion bans would literally infringe on the religious freedom of the Orthodox Jewish community.
Further amplifying this point, in sessions I have taught about abortion in Jewish law, I have included a quotation from a Hasidic medical professional who says: “It is nearly impossible to create a law that limits abortion and does not put a secular legal ban on some halachically permissible abortions. What Jewish community would want to continue to live in a place where they are potentially barred from following halacha? Is a community even allowed by halacha to continue living in such a place, if they have the option of leaving? It appears to me that the Jewish community cannot justify staying on the sidelines of this national American issue. We need to take the side of allowing for safe, legal, available abortions. Jewish law does not align with the Christian right on this issue, and neither should Orthodox Jews.” (https://www.jta.org/2019/05/22/opinion/what-jewish-law-really-says-about-abortion)
Most people who have abortions do not make this decision cavalierly. It is almost always a “pro-life” decision in the most literal sense, in that it is a decision made out of anguished concern for the pregnant person’s health and wellbeing, or for the needs of other family members, or of potential future children. This has been reinforced for me in so many conversations I have had with people who are contemplating abortion or have had an abortion. And the spectre of a country where women are scared to get pre-natal care, where every miscarriage is treated as a potential criminal investigation, and where doctors hesitate to perform abortions that they believe are necessary to save the life of the mother (because they could be second-guessed after the fact by other doctors, or non-doctors, who suggest that the abortion was actually not the only way to save the life of the mother, potentially resulting in doctors serving jail time for making their best professional judgments on behalf of their patients), sounds terrifyingly dangerous.
Some of you know that my brother Mike works as the business and development director of a health care center in Virginia that provides abortions as well as other health care services. He has also volunteered for many years as a clinic escort, helping clients to walk into the clinics and giving them the strength to walk through the lines of protesters calling them vile names and assuming the worst about their intentions and their integrity. Shortly after I heard about the Supreme Court decision, I contributed in his honor to the National Council of Jewish Women’s Abortion Access Fund, https://www.jewsforabortionaccess.org/fund, which supports a long-standing network of organizations that give guidance and financial support to women nationwide about their options and provide financial assistance to those seeking abortions. I do not presume that everyone in our community agrees with what I have written -- but for those who do, this may be an example of tangible action that can make a real difference at a difficult time.
I am listing some additional links and articles below.
With best wishes for health and strength,
Rabbi Rob Scheinberg
some links for additional reading and listening:
Rabbi Elhanan Poupko, September 2021: https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/texas-abortion-law-an-assualt-on-orthodox-judaism/ -- a critique of the Texas abortion law from an Orthodox perspective. Subtitle: “This ban is not really a pro-life stance; rather, it is forcing fundamentalist Christian beliefs on the many who do not share those beliefs.” ( I am not Orthodox, but I share these Orthodox writings because most people reading this already know that non-Orthodox Jews are overwhelmingly likely to take the pro-choice perspective.)
I began my sermon with a brief description of my trip to Pittsburgh this January to spend a shabbat filling in for Rabbi Jonathan Perlman at the New Light Congregation, which lost 3 congregants in the terrible Tree of Life massacre. (If you are curious why I have chosen the spelling ‘antisemitism’ (uncapitalized and without a hyphen), see here. ) ….Rabbi Perlman’s community, called New Light, used to have its own building, but a few years ago they sold their building and began to rent space from the Tree of Life synagogue. Rabbi Perlman says he had never heard live gunfire before, but the moment he heard the sound, he knew what it was and that he had to hide and get others into hiding. He was able to hustle the other three people with him at the front of the room into a safe area, an electrical storage closet behind the wall where the aron kodesh, holy ark is. So in that storage closet, which was pitch-black because they couldn’t find the light switch -- were four people: R
The Hebrew and Yiddish writer and Zionist leader Shmaryahu Levin would tell a story of a transformative incident that took place when he was age 10, in Eastern Europe. He received a gift of his very own Shofar. So as Rosh HaShanah approached, he was so excited to practice blowing the Shofar. But try as he could, he just couldn’t get any sound out of it at all. Each day, during the month of Elul leading up to Rosh HaShanah, he would spend at least an hour - holding his mouth in various positions, making various kinds of rude vibrating noises with his lips, trying to produce any sound with the Shofar. But to no avail. The day before Rosh HaShanah, as he was practicing outside his home, a Russian farmer came by. “What’s that?” So he explained it, and the farmer said, “Can I try?” and he took the Shofar, held it up to his lips - and out came a Tekiah Gedolah that would be the envy of any Shofar-blower in the world. And young Shmaryahu raced back to his teacher and choking back tea
Last November, the record was set in Israel for the most expensive document ever to be sold at auction in Israel. The story of that document starts nearly 100 years ago. In 1922, Albert Einstein had recently learned that he had won the Nobel Prize. He had a previously scheduled lecture in Tokyo, so in Tokyo he was receiving numerous letters and telegrams congratulating him on winning the Nobel Prize. Someone had sent him a package, so a bellboy from the hotel came up to deliver the package to Einstein, who looked in his pocket to find some change to give as a tip to the bellboy. But he didn’t have any. So he told the bellboy instead: “Let me write you a note. Maybe someday it will become more valuable than a regular tip. And if not, then well I’m just giving you some good advice from my experience.” So he wrote, in German, on the Japanese hotel stationery, these words: “A calm and modest life brings more happiness than the pursuit of success combined with constant restlessn