Hatikvah - the Untold Story

By -


Last Saturday night I taught a session called "Hatikvah - the Untold Story" at the Sweet Tastes of Torah community event in Fair Lawn NJ.  It was an exciting way for me to combine my interests in Israel, Jewish liturgical poetry, and music.

Here are some links to the resources I discussed about the evolution of the words and music of Hatikvah.

Words:

my source sheet

 http://www.piyut.org.il/textual/359.html - Naftali Hertz Imber's original poem 'Tikvateinu'

http://www.musiccathedra.bravehost.com/hatikva.wmv and http://www.musiccathedra.bravehost.com/ch10.wmv - Hebrew video interviews with Astrith Baltsan about her book about Hatikvah, including discussion of the words and musical examples.
Music:

 http://youtu.be/lDJUDqtxK6M - early recording of Hatikvah, 1918, by Alma Gluck and Efrem Zimbalist Jr  (using 'the old words')

http://youtu.be/adTjy-TIW_Q - Romanian folk song "Carul Cu Boi" ("A cart with oxen") -- the melody that Romanian immigrant Samuel Cohen (Rishon Letzion) suggested for Hatikvah

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ifJ8JXVJRo - La Montavana - Italian song with similar melody

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMst624lBrA - Fuggi la questa cielo (starting around 2'15") - Italian love song based on La Montavana

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BTvoqVK420 (broken link replaced 5-2019) - Mozart's 12 Variations 'Ah vous dirai-je Maman'  (otherwise known as 'Twinkle Twinkle Little Star').  Variation #8 (starting at 4'12") sounds remarkably similar to Hatikvah / Carul Cu Boi / La Montavana  -- in the session we speculated on why that might be.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOxIbhqZsKc -- Smetana's "Moldau"  (Vltava) from "Ma Vlast" -- starting around 1'05" - the most famous statement of the "Hatikvah" theme in Western classical music.  In the session we talked about how Smetana used folk materials in his composition, and that "The Moldau" sounds like Hatikvah not because Hatikvah is based on "The Moldau," but because both are based on similar earlier folk motifs.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=syUSmEbGLs4 -- perhaps the most emotional recording of Hatikvah, from 5 days after the liberation of Bergen-Belsen in 1945.

Addition in 2019:  Also listen to the Hatikvah podcast by Israel Story:  https://israelstory.org/episode/36-mixtape-part-hope/

Comments

  1. Samuel Eitan CohenFebruary 8, 2012 at 9:43 AM

    Toda Raba Rabbi Scheinberg for this amazing collection and the research and time you spent to show it all to us.

    Eitan Cohen

    ReplyDelete
  2. UnknownFebruary 5, 2013 at 3:00 PM

    Rabbi, have you done any research to share about Purim music
    Todah rabah.
    Linda Buxbaum
    Temple Beth Israel, Long Boat Key, Florida

    ReplyDelete
  3. LbYvSGJune 11, 2014 at 9:01 AM

    "The Moldau" sounds like Hatikvah not because Hatikvah is based on "The Moldau," but because both are based on similar earlier folk motifs.

    Thank you. I always wondered why I thought of Hatikvah when hearing "The Moldau".

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What happened to Haman's descendants?

By -
Image
On the surface, Purim seems like the most lighthearted Jewish holiday, with joking, masquerading, feasting, and delivering treats to friends and family.   But under that surface boils the powerful rage of thousands of years.   When we yell and stamp and make noise during the reading of the Megillah, we express our rage not only at Haman, the villain of the Purim story, but also at those in every generation whose irrational hatred of Jews has led them to violence.   But let us exhibit this rage with caution. The rage of Purim finds dramatic expression in the special Torah reading for the Shabbat before Purim, known as Shabbat Zakhor, the Sabbath of Remembrance. We read (Deuteronomy 25:17-19)   that as the Israelites were wandering in the desert, they were attacked by the tribe of Amalek. The Amalekites chose to fight their battle not against the armed Israelite soldiers, but against innocent, defenseless civilians, the “stragglers in the rear.” The Torah command...
Read more

Two words for "husband": Haftarah Bamidbar

By -
Image
From the Shofar Newsletter May 2013   What’s the Hebrew word for ‘husband’? Actually, you have two choices.  Both are in use in Hebrew today.  and both were used in the time of the bible.  The first word is ‘ ba’al ’.  If a woman in Israel today wants to refer to her husband, she might refer to him as ‘ ba’ali ’ - ‘my husband.’ But if you know Hebrew, you know that the same word ‘ baal ’ can mean ‘owner.’  For example, ‘ ba’al ha-bayit ’ means ‘home-owner’ or ‘master of the house.’  And more insidiously, the owner of a slave is also referred to in the bible as ‘ baal ’. So you can see this term’s etymological origin.  It is a relic of a time when a woman’s relationship with her husband wasn’t that different from the relationship between a servant and master.  There are some people who won’t use the word baal on principle for this reason.  So what word would they use instead?  The word ‘ ish ’.  Most liter...
Read more

Teaching Torah about a catastrophic year (First day of Rosh HaShanah 5785 / 2024)

By -
Image
First day of Rosh HaShanah 5785 / 2024: Teaching Torah about a catastrophic year Rabbi Robert Scheinberg United Synagogue of Hoboken So a rabbi applies for a position at a synagogue and is invited to an “audition shabbat” to meet the community and give a sermon.   The week before, the chair of the search committee calls and says:  “I’m just curious what you’re planning to talk about when you come for your audition shabbat.”  And the rabbi says:  “I was going to speak about the centrality of Shabbat in living a Jewish life today.” and the search committee chair says:  “Rabbi, let me give you some advice.  People in this synagogue don’t observe Shabbat. They will feel judged and uncomfortable if you talk about shabbat.” And the rabbi says:  “Well, ok.  I guess I could speak about how Judaism has a system for affirming the holiness of everyday actions like eating, which is the system of Kashrut-”  And the search committee chair breaks in....
Read more